Martin Scorsese’s latest film, the historical drama Silence, is like that sequence stretched to feature length. It’s about an overriding belief in the goodness of the almighty and of divine justice, and then having that certitude tested to its very limit. At what point does a person’s faith reach its breaking point? Along with fellow priest Garrpe (Adam Driver), Rodrigues goes to Japan to find Ferreira and save his tarnished reputation. But the country’s is in the grip of a fearsome inquisition, headed up by Inoue Masashige (Issey Ogata), which aims to expunge Christianity from its shores through torture and execution. Rodrigues and Garrpe arrive there eager to serve and thrilled at the fortitude of the faithful Japanese Christians – largely poor village folk – they find there. Gradually, however, their morale deserts them, and the film’s title begins to take on a disturbing new meaning: the silence is not just of a religious group quaking in its huts, fearful of being uncovered, but of God himself. Through all the pain and torment meted out by the inquisition, the Almighty’s silence remains deafening. With cinematographer Rodrigo Prieto, Scorsese generates a deeply uneasy film of physical and psychological torment. Aerial shots in Rodrigues’ native Portugal suggest that God is in his heaven looking down and all is in its right place. The deeper Rodrigues journeys into Japan, the lower and closer the camera gets to its subjects; muddied, blooded hands gripping little wooden crosses, faces streaked with tears. In The Last Temptation Of Christ, Scorsese controversially imagined a very human messiah who struggles with the mental and physical frailties of his mortal body. In Silence, adapted from the novel by Shusaku Endo, Scorsese very deliberately draws parallels between Rodrigues’ suffering and that of Christ; both are dragged into a hostile wilderness; both are jeered at and betrayed; both wind up openly questioning why God has abandoned them. Importantly, Silence isn’t one of those films that depicts the white guys as saviours and everyone else as villains. The Japanese heavies who operate under Masashige’s aegis are heartless, certainly, but the suffering they mete out is to their own people; other Japanese, often poor, penniless villagers, who’ve done nothing more than worship the ‘wrong’ deity. As in so many of Scorsese’s other films, from Mean Streets onwards, Silence isn’t interested in good and evil, but in the moral hinterland between them, and where God’s grace, goodness and justice might fit. Silence is a philosophical film, and some of the questions it asks probably aren’t very fashionable in 2016 – hence, perhaps, Scorsese’s absence from this year’s Golden Globe nominations. Those questions include, but aren’t limited to: how often can a man sin and still be forgiven? If God exists, why does he allow us to suffer? Is it better to stand up for our values – whether religious or otherwise – or is martyrdom really an act of selfishness? Neither Rodrigues nor Scorsese offer immediate answers; they simply bear witness, and only hint at their own conclusions. Silence is out in UK cinemas on the 1st January.
Silence Review
<span title='2025-08-17 00:00:00 +0000 UTC'>August 17, 2025</span> · 3 min · 514 words · Dolores Rider